Surgical treatment strategy in Warthin tumor of the parotid gland / Estratégia de tratamento cirúrgico no tumor de Warthin de glândula parótida

Abstract Introduction: Warthin tumors are the second most common benign tumors of the parotid gland. We examined the clinical features of Warthin tumors in our hospital, and analyzed the consistency within the literatures. Objective: The aim of this study is to analyze the clinical features of Warthin tumors in our 10-year experience of 118 Warthin tumors undergoing surgery at a single institute. Methods: From December 2006 to December 2016, 110 patients who underwent surgical treatment for Warthin tumors were identified based on their medical records. Results: A total of 118 parotid gland operations were performed in 110 patients. Almost 90% of Warthin tumors were found in males, and average patient age was 66.1 ± 6.1 years. The prevalence of smoking history was 89.1% (98/110). Eight patients (7.3%) had bilateral Warthin tumors. Seventy-seven lesions (65.3%) were located in the parotid tail portion, followed by 34 lesions in the superficial lobe (28.8%) and 7 lesions in the deep lobe (5.9%). Conclusion: We determined the appropriate extent of surgery depending on the fine needle aspiration cytology and tumor location by computed tomography scans. Partial facial dysfunction after the operation was detected in 12 cases, and facial nerve function recovered within 3 months. Only one patient experienced a recurrence, and was disease free after the re-operation. We suggest that our treatment algorithm, depending on the location of tumors and the result of fine needle aspiration cytology, can be useful to determine the appropriate extent of surgery for Warthin tumors.

Resumo Introdução: Os tumores de Warthin são os segundos tumores benignos mais comuns da glândula parótida. Avaliamos as características clínicas dos tumores de Warthin em nosso hospital e analisamos a consistência com a literatura. Objetivo: Analisar as características clínicas dos tumores de Warthin em nossa experiência de 10 anos de 118 tumores de Warthin submetidos a tratamento cirúrgico em um único instituto. Método: De dezembro de 2006 a dezembro de 2016, 110 pacientes que receberam tratamento cirúrgico para tumores de Warthin foram identificados com base em seus prontuários médicos. Resultados: Foram feitas 118 cirurgias na glândula parótida em 110 pacientes. Quase 90% dos tumores de Warthin foram encontrados em homens e a média da idade dos pacientes foi de 66,1 ± 6,1 anos. A prevalência de tabagismo foi de 89,1% (98/110). Oito pacientes (7,3%) tinham tumores de Warthin bilaterais na glândula parótida. Das lesões, 77 (65,3%) localizavam-se na porção da cauda da parótida, seguidas por 34 no lobo superficial (28,8%) e 7 no lobo profundo (5,9%). Conclusão: Determinamos a extensão apropriada da cirurgia de acordo com a punção aspirativa com agulha fina e localização do tumor por tomografia computadorizada. Disfunção facial parcial após a cirurgia foi detectada em 12 casos e a função do nervo facial foi recuperada em 3 meses. Apenas um paciente apresentou recidiva e ficou livre da doença após reoperação. Sugerimos que nosso algoritmo de tratamento, a depender da localização dos tumores e do resultado da PAAF, pode ser útil para determinar a extensão apropriada da cirurgia para os tumores de Warthin.

Tumor de Warthin: Una experiencia del Hospital «General Calixto García¼. La Habana, Cuba / Warthin's tumor: An experience of the General Hospital «Calixto García¼. Havana, Cuba

Antecedentes: El tumor de Warthin -tumor benigno de glándulas salivales- fue reportado por primera vez en 1895 por Hildebrand y posteriormente en 1929 Warthin lo describió ampliamente. Es la segunda neoplasia más frecuente de las glándulas salivales, representando el 10% de todos los tumores de glándulas salivales. Métodos: Se realizó un estudio retrospectivo de tumores de glándulas salivales del Departamento de Anatomía Patológica del Hospital «Calixto García¼ de La Habana, Cuba, durante el periodo de enero del 2001 a diciembre del 2008. Los casos fueron rediagnosticados por dos expertos en patología bucal, basados en los criterios diagnósticos propuestos por la Organización Mundial de la Salud en el 2005. Resultados: De 159 casos, 113 (71.1%) fueron tumores benignos (48 hombres, 65 mujeres; promedio de edad 50.8 [± 15], rango de edad 20-80 años). El tumor más frecuente fue el adenoma pleomorfo con 77 casos (68.1%), seguido del tumor de Warthin con 33 casos, que constituyen el 20.7% del total de tumores de glándulas salivales incluidos y el 29.2% del total de los tumores benignos. Conclusiones: En nuestro estudio la proporción del tumor de Warthin está dentro de las más altas, acorde a lo reportado en la literatura de los últimos años.

Background: Warthin's tumor, a benign tumor of the salivary glands, was first described by Dr. Hildrebrand in 1896. It was later extensively described by Dr. Warthin in 1929. It represents the second most frequent neoplasia found in the salivary glands. It constitutes 10% of all salivary glands tumors. Methods: A salivary gland retrospective study was conducted at the Pathological Anatomy Department of the «Calixto García¼ Hospital in Havana, Cuba. The study was conducted in the period comprised between January 2001 and December 2008. Two oral pathology experts re-diagnosed the cases following diagnostic criteria proposed in 2005 by the World Health Organization (WHO). Results: Out of 159 studied cases, 113 (71.1%) were benign tumors (48 male patients, 65 female, average age 50.8 [± 15], age range 20-80 years). Most frequently found tumor was pleomorphic adenoma, which counted 77 cases (68.1%) followed by Warthin's tumor with 33 cases (20.7%) of all included salivary glands tumors and 29.2% of benign tumors. Conclusions: The present study revealed the fact that Warthin's tumor proportion is among the highest reported in recent years in scientific literature.

Tratamiento quirúrgico de los tumores de parótida: experiencia de 10 años / Surgical treatment of parotid neoplasms: a 10 years experience

Background: Parotid neoplasms correspond to 3 percent of head and neck tumors. Most are benign, treatment is parotidectomy. Aims: To analyze the results of treatment, histology, complications and recurrence. Patients and Methods: Retrospective analysis of patients with parotid tumors treated in our center among 2001-2010. Results: The series consisted of 82 patients, 52 (63 percent) women. Average age: 46 years (range, 17-77), 73 (89 percent) had benign tumors, 7 (8.5 percent) were malignant and 2 (2.4 percent) had chronic inflammatory disease. The most common benign tumors were pleomorphic adenoma (55 percent) and Warthin's tumor (20 percent). The most common malignant tumors were mucoepidermoid carcinoma (5 percent) and acinar cell carcinoma (4 percent). The technique was total parotidectomy in 10 patients (12 percent), total suprafacial 53 (64.6 percent) and partial in 19 (23 percent). The most common complication was transient facial nerve dysfunction in the immediate postoperative period in 38 cases (46.3 percent), 14 (17 percent) had surgical bed depression, 15 (18.3 percent), dysesthesia periauricular, 2 (2.4 percent) permanent paralysis of the facial nerve (tumor) and 6 (7.3 percent) Frey Syndrome. No patient had a disagreement with his scar and pain periauricular, there were no recurrences. There was lesser transient facial nerve paralysis with partial suprafacial parotidectomy than with total suprafacial parotidectomy (21 percent and 53 percent), RR 0.4 IC 95 percent (0.16-0.99). Discussion: The application of less invasive surgical techniques such as partial parotidectomy suprafacial allow comparable results in benign conditions, with low morbidity without increasing recurrence.

Introducción: Las neoplasias parotídeas corresponden al 3 por ciento de los tumores de cabeza y cuello. La mayoría son benignas, el tratamiento es la parotidectomía. Objetivo: Analizar los resultados del tratamiento, histología, complicaciones y recurrencia. Pacientes y Métodos: Análisis retrospectivo de los pacientes con tumores parotídeas intervenidos en nuestro centro entre 2001-2010. Resultados: La serie estuvo compuesta por 82 pacientes, 52 (63 por ciento) mujeres. La edad promedio: 46 años (rango, 17-77); 73 (89 por ciento) tuvieron tumores benignos, 7 (8,5 por ciento) malignos y 2 (2,4 por ciento) presentaron enfermedad inflamatoria crónica. Los tumores benignos más frecuentes fueron el adenoma pleomorfo (55 por ciento) y el tumor de Warthin (20 por ciento). Los tumores malignos más frecuentes fueron el carcinoma mucoepidermoide (5 por ciento) y el carcinoma de células acinares (4 por ciento). La técnica fue parotidectomía total en 10 pacientes (12 por ciento), suprafacial total en 53 (64,6 por ciento) y parcial en 19 (23 por ciento). La complicación más frecuente fue la disfunción transitoria del nervio facial en el postoperatorio inmediato en 38 casos (46,3 por ciento); 14 (17 por ciento) presentaron depresión del lecho operatorio, 15 (18,3 por ciento) disestesia periauricular, 2 (2,4 por ciento) parálisis permanente del nervio facial (tumor maligno) y 6 (7,3 por ciento) Síndrome de Frey. Ningún paciente presentó disconformidad con su cicatriz ni dolor periauricular; no hubo recidivas. Se observó menos parálisis transitoria del nervio facial con la parotidectomía suprafacial parcial que con la parotidectomía suprafacial total (21 por ciento y 53 por ciento, respectivamente), RR 0,4 IC 95 por ciento (0,16-0,99). Discusión: La aplicación de técnicas quirúrgicas menos agresivas como la parotidectomía suprafacial parcial permite obtener resultados comparables en patologías benignas, con bajas tasas de morbilidad, sin aumentar la recurrencia.

Consideraciones anatómicas en la parotidectomía: revisión de la literatura a propósito de un caso / Anatomical considerations in parotidectomy: review of the literature and case report

La parotidectomía es un procedimiento quirúrgico habitualmente realizado por Cirujanos Maxilofaciales y Cirujanos de Cabeza y Cuello, en el cual se remueve parcialmente o en su totalidad a la glándula parótida. Las indicaciones más comunes para éste procedimiento son las neoplasias de la glándula. Aproximadamente el 80% del total de los tumores de glándulas salivales ocurren en la parótida. De estos, el 75-80% son de naturaleza benigna. Sin embargo, la parotidectomía es un procedimiento sumamente complejo debido a la anatomía regional y por la íntima relación de la glándula parótida con el nervio facial. Siendo la clave de este procedimiento la preservación funcional de éste nervio y de sus ramos. Por lo tanto el conocimiento acabado de la anatomía de la glándula parótida y de sus estructuras anexas es necesario para el éxito quirúrgico. Esta revisión y reporte de caso discutirá las consideraciones anatómicas que deben tenerse durante la parotidectomía para disminuir la posibilidad de alguna complicación.

Parotidectomy is a surgical procedure usually performed by Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons and Head and Neck Surgeons, in which the parotid gland may be removed partially or totally. The most common indications for this procedure are the neoplasms of the gland. Approximately 80% of total salivary gland tumors occur in the parotid gland. Of these, 75-80% are benign. However, the parotidectomy is a highly complex procedure because of the regional anatomy and the close relationship of the parotid gland with the facial nerve. The most important aspect of this procedure is the functional preservation of the facial nerve and its branches. Therefore, the thorough knowledge of the anatomy of the parotid gland and related structures is necessary for surgical success. This review and case report will discuss the anatomical considerations that must be taken during parotidectomy to reduce the possibility of complications.